JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — A new Missouri law designed to give violent juvenile criminals a second chance is also clearing the way for a man who, when he was 17, murdered his friend as part of a Satanic ritual, to have the chance at parole.
On Wednesday, July 12, Governor Jay Nixon signed into law Senate Bill 590 which brings Missouri criminal code into alignment with the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in Miller v. Alabama (2012). The law applies to James M. Hardy’s motion recently heard before Judge Hayden.
In the Miller decision, the Supreme Court said a defendant who was under the age of 18 at the time he or she committed a murder could not receive a sentence of life without parole. The court argued that a statutory minimum sentence of life without the possibility of probation or parole does not allow the court to consider the primary factors of youth such as a propensity to ignore consequences of reckless behavior, mitigating factors in a defendant’s home life which the juvenile mind has little ability to overcome or resist, and the fact that youthful offenders are the very best candidates for rehabilitation and successful return to a productive life in society.
The logic of Miller is that automatically applying the harshest penalty in a case where the young defendant had the least likelihood of being a hardened and depraved repeat offender violates the very essence of the 8th Amendment, which prohibits cruel and unusual punishment.
This issue is currently playing out in a case first heard in Circuit Court of Camden County in 1988. Three high school students in Jasper County were charged with 1st Degree Murder after they beat a fellow student to death with a baseball bat during a Satanic ritual where they had been sacrificing an animal. In a change of venue, James M. Hardy appeared in Camden County where he accepted a plea arrangement. The prosecution allowed him to plead guilty to the crime and accept life without the possibility of parole to avoid a trial where he might have been sentenced to death.
Following the advice of his attorney and his mother, James Hardy agreed to the deal. Since then, Hardy has challenged his incarceration through the Appellate and Missouri Supreme Court, and each time, was denied. In 2016, Hardy appeared in Camden County court to argue for a motion to withdraw his plea of guilt.
Judge Hayden with the 26th Circuit, the court of original jurisdiction, denied the motion. Hayden cited Montgomery v Louisiana (2016). In that decision, defendants sentenced to life without the possibility of parole are directed to apply for parole after serving 25 years.
Before SB 590 was signed by Governor Jay Nixon, juvenile offenders who committed first degree murder before the age of 18 were sentenced to life without probation, parole, or a conditional release even though the 2012 Miller decision rendered that unconstitutional. Consequently, there was no enforceable punishment for first degree murder against those who committed murder before they turned 18. SB 590 amends Missouri’s criminal code to provide an enforceable punishment and a remedy for those sentenced under previous statues.
Missouri’s law not only repeals the mandatory life sentence found to be unconstitutional in Miller v. Alabama, but it also provides three possible sentences for a judge or jury to declare: 1) life with eligibility for parole, 2) a term of imprisonment at least 30 years and not more than 40 years, and 3) life without eligibility for parole if the prosecutor demonstrates that torture was involved and warrants life without the possibility of parole.
This third sentence under SB 590 may affect a case like Hardy’s in the future—as his crime involved torture—but the Supreme Court decision makes it clear he has the right to apply for parole, as he has served more than 25 years in prison.
