Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Featured

Last Attempt At Justice Prevails: Aaron Fisher Sentenced To 15 Years For Assaulting His Infant Daughter

Aaron Fisher pleaded guilty to Assault, after all other possible charges had been dismissed

  • Updated
  • 4 min to read
Aaron Michael Fisher

LACLEDE COUNTY, Mo. — The notorious case against Aaron Fisher has finally come to an end.

On Friday, Jan. 19 at the Laclede County Courthouse, Fisher pleaded guilty to 1st degree Assault and was sentenced to 15 years in prison.

Fisher was charged with sodomizing his infant daughter in 2009, but had been released on a technicality when Cole County Judge Patricia Joyce said that after six years in jail his right to a speedy trial had been violated. (Joyce had the case because both 26th Circuit judges had recused themselves. Meanwhile, while Fisher awaited trial, he served time for a felony charge of destroying jail property.)

Joyce's decision was met with outrage from the Lake community, and even State Representative Rocky Miller said he thought Joyce should possibly be impeached for the decision. That never happened, but the overburdened 26th Circuit (which includes Camden, Laclede, Miller, Moniteau, and Morgan counties) became the focus of legislation.

The circuit was in need of two additional judges, according to an analysis used by the state, and the shortage was creating a major logjam. Fisher's case was one of many that had been caught in the 26th circuit's seemingly endless cycle of delays, but in this case, a man who had openly admitted to an unspeakable crime walked free as a result. So in 2016, the Missouri legislature acted. The 26th Circuit received a third judge, and justice began moving more quickly.

About a year after Fisher was released from prison, he was arrested again for the same original incident, but on different charges: 1st Degree Assault against the five-month-old.

On Friday, Fisher took Miller County Prosecutor Ben Winfrey's open plea offer without agreeing on a sentencing amount, knowing that there would be a cap of 20 years. He is required to serve 85% of the 15 year sentence before he is eligible for parole. If Fisher serves his entire sentence, he will have served a total of 21 years in connection with the crime, considering the six years he served while awaiting trial for the original charges.

Read more about those six years and the delays... [article continues below]

On Friday, at the sentencing hearing, the prosecution produced evidence of the abuse and Fisher was required to verbally admit his guilt as the judge read each charge. 

Prosecutor Winfrey inherited the case from his predecessor in 2014, and after the case was dismissed in 2015, Winfrey was nearly out of options. He brought the Assault charge against Fisher and it withstood a motion for dismissal from the defense because Fisher had not actually been charged with Assault in connection with the brutal 2009 incident (which he admitted to in open court during the original trial proceedings). Fisher was bringing a set of evidence to the trial in charging Fisher with Assault, and hoping this final attempt would render some modicum of justice for the crime.

On Friday, Winfrey told LakeExpo.com, “It was a lot of work, but I am proud to have done it. I acknowledge that there is no adequate remedy for the things that he did. The closest we could get to it was to finally get a guilty verdict… and have a decent-sized result in terms of a prison sentence.” 

Fisher had waived his right to jury sentencing, and Winfrey's offer was set to expire on Friday. In court, Fisher unexpectedly took the deal.

Is Winfrey happy with the outcome? "I don’t know about 'happy,'" he said. "I’m sorry it doesn’t fix things for the victims." But, he emphasized, "This was an attempt to give the victim and the family some closure."

The trial for a Brumley man who admitted to sodomizing his infant daughter—but who walked free on a technicality—stopped not long after it began this week. Now, Aaron Fisher’s case has been reset for Jan. 19.

0
0
1
1
3

(1 Ratings)