Aaron Michael Fisher

Aaron Fisher, a Brumley man who confessed to raping his infant daughter but never stood trial after his case was dismissed, has now been charged with 1st Degree Assault in Miller County.

Facebook photo

The state is running out of options in the rape and sodomy case against Aaron Fisher. The Missouri Western District Appellate Court says it will not rehear the case against Fisher, and now the state has a short window of time to take the issue to the state Supreme Court.

On Dec. 7, 2016, Daniel Neal McPherson of the Missouri State Attorney General’s Office filed a Motion for Rehearing of the Aaron Fisher appeal in the Western District Appellate Court of Missouri. 

McPherson's filing came after the Appellate Court earlier this fall upheld a 2015 ruling by Judge Patricia Joyce of Cole County. Joyce had ruled that the Fisher case had dragged on for too long, thereby denying Fisher his constitutional right to a speedy trial. So she dismissed the case against him—which had lasted for more than six years without resolution—and he was set free.

McPherson’s motion made in behalf of the State not only asked the Appellate Court to reconsider its earlier unanimous decision, but the motion is also a necessary prerequisite before the Supreme Court would consider the matter.

On Dec. 16, 2016, the state’s motion for rehearing was overruled and denied.

The State now has fifteen days to file a request with the Supreme Court for it to hear the appeal and examine Judge Joyce’s decision.

After his 2015 dismissal, Fisher was released and promptly left the state. Recently Ben Winfrey, current Miller County Prosecutor, filed a new charge of 1st Degree Assault against Fisher based upon the original attack by Fisher upon the infant. Information relating to Fisher’s whereabouts developed by LakeExpo.com facilitated Fisher’s arrest on this new charge.

The original charge against Fisher involved sexual molestation of a minor child. Fisher admitted to the charge when interviewed by investigators, and also confessed to the crime in open court. The Circuit Court in Miller County ruled there could be no admission and guilty plea because of discrepancies in Fisher’s confession. Fisher, at his sentencing hearing, stated he had no recollection of the events as he described them in his admissions to the police.

Citing the case record in the original Miller County case, Judge Joyce in 2015 found that the state had failed to bring Fisher to trial for six years. Joyce further found that Matt Howard, the Miller County Prosecuting Attorney at the time of the crime, was at fault for not advancing the matter to trial in a timely manner. 

The state, through McPherson, filed an appeal in the Western District Appellate Division, seeking to have Judge Joyce’s ruling overturned and the case reinstated. The Western District, in a unanimous opinion, affirmed the Joyce ruling and agreed in detailed language with the findings that Fisher had been denied the right to a speedy trial.


0
0
0
0
0

(0 Ratings)