CAMDEN COUNTY, Mo. — Justice moves too slowly around the Lake of the Ozarks: virtually everyone agrees. But the impending appointment of a third judge to the 26th Circuit will inarguably speed things along, helping the innocent more quickly vindicate themselves and the guilty more assuredly receive their penalty.
In 2015, after proceedings had lasted more than four years, Cole County Presiding Judge Patricia Joyce dismissed the case against Miller County resident Aaron Fisher and ordered his release. She agreed with Fisher's attorney who argued the defendant had been denied his constitutional right to a speedy trial. Fisher had been awaiting trial for the rape of his five-month-old daughter and had, multiple times, admitted to his guilt, according to charging documents and the former prosecutor who initially took up the case. His release on constitutional grounds added to a sense of urgency among lawmakers resolved not to repeat the Fisher outcome. In 2016, they acted to add a third judge in the 26th Circuit. The impact of that third judge could be significant in speeding justice along, around the Lake of the Ozarks.
According to Judge Kenneth M. Hayden, the idea for adding a third judge in this circuit dates back to 1987 when Sen. John T. Russell of Laclede County introduced the first of many bills designed to bring relief. The recent one that authorized a third judge was introduced by Rep. Rocky Miller and supported by area legislators. Its passage will result in a gubernatorial appointment—which could happen before the end of the year.
Miller confirmed Nixon has been interviewing candidates and is "serious" about at least a couple of them, but that the governor will likely wait until after the Nov. 8 election date to make the appointment.
As evidenced by the Fisher case, the need for a new judge was palpable, and even quantifiable. Statistics for 2015 compiled by the Missouri Office of State Courts Administrator show only five circuits had more felony cases filed, more felony cases disposed of, and more felony cases pending than the 26th Circuit. Each of those five were all single-county circuits in the Kansas City, St. Louis, and Springfield areas. Each is a more heavily populated, metropolitan area compared to any of the five counties of the 26th: Camden, Laclede, Miller, Morgan and Moniteau. Prosecuting attorneys and sheriffs in those counties will now work with Presiding Judge Hayden to implement a three-judge schedule for the circuit, something Judge Hayden has already begun developing. Though a third judge has not been appointed yet, the circuit has already begun moving some cases over to that empty third slot, in the anticipation of an impending appointment.
Currently, the 26th has two Circuit Judges: Kenneth M. Hayden serving as Presiding Judge and Stanley Moore. Both travel to each of the five counties on a rotating schedule. In addition, there are Associate Judges who are specifically assigned in their respective counties. The associate circuit judges are Aaron Koeppen and Matt Hammer in Camden County; Steven B. Jackson and Larry Winfrey, Jr. in Laclede County; Jon Kaltenbronn in Miller County; Peggy Richardson in Moniteau County; and Kevin Schehr in Morgan County.
In the Associate Circuit Division, the associate circuit judge may hear and decide in all criminal misdemeanors and infractions. An associate circuit judge may also begin a felony criminal case by conducting a preliminary hearing to determine probable cause, and if probable cause is found to exist, the defendant is bound over for trial in the circuit court. The associate circuit judge also hears civil cases.
The Presiding Judge can assign an Associate Judge to hear a case in another county. However, Judge Hayden noted that assigning an associate in this way leaves the associate’s bench empty in his or her home county and thus adversely impacts that county’s docket, as nothing could be scheduled during the absence. Thus, while one matter might be expedited by reassigning an associate judge to another county, his or her absence would create a backlog in his/her regular assignment. Judge Hayden stated all the associate judges in the 26th Circuit are extremely gracious and understanding when called upon in this manner.
Legislators, prosecutors, and judges agree that having a third judge in a five-county district with one or more associate judges available in each county will make a difference without doubt. Although the number of criminal cases filed will likely remain static, as that number derives from the population and staffing levels in law enforcement, a third judge will ensure that cases to and from associate judges flow more smoothly. According to Judge Hayden, the three-judge schedule allows for a reallocation of judicial resources across the five counties. For example, a third judge could increase Moniteau County’s five-day jury week in civil matters from two per calendar year to four and its criminal jury weeks from two to six per year.
Currently, Judges Hayden and Moore each serve in Moniteau two weeks annually, one for civil trials and one for criminal proceedings. It is only during this five-day block of time on that county’s calendar that a trial may be scheduled. If a trial is rescheduled as a result of a motion for continuance from the defense or prosecution, it must get in line behind other cases already set for one of those weeks or bump another case already scheduled. In either situation, someone’s day in court will be delayed due to calendar limitations for each judge in each county.
One example of this is the currently pending case of Susan Elizabeth Van Note. In December of 2015 the court reset her jury trial for January of 2017. Although many cases have trial and hearing dates reset for six to eight months in the future, others cannot be scheduled as quickly due to anticipated days needed to try the case or full jury weeks in a reasonable timeframe with only two judges.
Given the fact that most trials cannot be conducted in less than one day and many require three to four days for jury selection, opening statements by both parties, examination of witnesses and evidence plus jury deliberations, moving more than one case forward to completion in a jury-week is rare. Disposal of more than two felony cases would be nearly impossible. A third judge will simply allow more cases to be heard in a single county.
Attorney Tim Cisar explained to LakeExpo that one of the additional benefits beyond moving the criminal docket along faster will be faster movement in the civil docket. A citizen’s right to have a court settle their civil dispute where harm has come because of accidental or negligent action by another is an important concept of our legal system. Like criminal law, a civil action can be made more difficult by the undue passage of time as witnesses and evidence are lost and memory dims.
The actual budget of the circuit court should not be impacted, as the salary of both the additional judge and the additional court reporter are paid by the State of Missouri. Furthermore, Camden is the host county for the 26th Circuit and already has sufficient office space and furnishings to accommodate an additional judge. Most of the counties in the 26th have sufficient courtrooms to allow for more court days. Even in Moniteau, the one county with only a single courtroom, an additional judge will still have available court space as the single courtroom is not in use five days each week.
Budget impacts on other agencies, however, remain to be seen.
