The video surveillance tape of Kelsey Smith leaving an Overland Park Target last June shows that the 18-year-old was abducted, a forensic video analyst testified Wednesday.

The abduction easily could have been overlooked by police officers during their initial viewings because of the format in which those viewings occurred, said Eddie Burns, who works for Target at its headquarters in Minneapolis. Once the digital tape was viewed with the appropriate display method, the abduction became visible, he said.

"All of the content was always there," Burns testified under questioning from Johnson County District Attorney Phill Kline.

The Target video, which was shown in court, was the focus of a three-hour hearing before District Court Judge Peter Ruddick. Defense attorneys for Edwin R. Hall had contended in a Feb. 29 court document that prosecutors were withholding video and other evidence that would favor their client. And Ruddick said last month he planned to get to the bottom of what was going on.

Kline said in court Wednesday that he had retained an outside auditor to ensure that all evidence and pertinent information in the case has been turned over to the defense. A report from the auditor should be available by an April 21 hearing, he said.

Hall, 27, of Olathe is charged with abducting, raping and strangling the Overland Park teen. Smith disappeared about 7 p.m. after leaving the Target store on June 2. Her body was found June 6 near Longview Lake.

Hall is scheduled to go on trial in September. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

After testimony Wednesday from a half-dozen witnesses, Ruddick said he thought progress was being made. He wants to hear more evidence at the April 21 hearing. Hopefully by then, Ruddick said, the defense will have received and examined the Target video.

Defense attorneys Paul Cramm and Carl Cornwell contended in the Feb. 29 document that they had not received any Target video, although they had been asking for it for months.

They also alleged that prosecutors were withholding Target video that Overland Park police officers saw the day after the abduction.

The officers wrote in police reports at the time that they didn't see anything suspicious when Smith walked to her car.

Defense attorneys have been seeking a copy of what the officers said they saw.

One of those officers, Detective James Sutterby, testified that he and another officer went to the Target store the day after Smith was abducted. They did not see anything suspicious occurring when Smith walked out to her car, he said.

However, Sutterby said, when he looked at the same video later with different equipment he was able to see the abduction sequence.

Police first saw the abduction when they took the video to the Overland Park fire training center and used better equipment there.

Burns, the forensic analyst, explained that the abduction sequence was not visible on the equipment at Target because the digital file was so large that it was compressed. In that situation, he said, it was "skipping frames."

With the right viewing equipment, the video shows Smith walking to her car, opening her passenger-side door to put her packages in and walking around to the driver's side. A blurry figure emerges at that point and pushes her inside, Burns said.

Cramm said he had not seen the video that Burns showed in court. Prosecutors provided hours of Target videotape but never narrowed it down to the pertinent timeframe or provided it in a format that could be viewed, Cramm said.

Kline said copies of the Target video had been made available to the defense months earlier; Kline's trial assistant testified the defense had picked up the tapes in September.

Also, Kline said, new copies have been available for pickup in the district attorney's office since March 21, and it's possible the defense did not realize they had the tapes because of the voluminous amount of material turned over to them.

Cramm said in court he planned to send the video to his expert immediately.

Afterward, Smith's parents, Greg and Missey Smith, said they were pleased with the hearing.

"It's very obvious there is just one video," Greg Smith said, "and the defense learned that it had had it since September."

@ Go to Kansas City.com for video from court Wednesday.

To reach Diane Carroll, call (816) 234-7704 or send e-mail to dcarroll@kcstar.com

To see more of The Kansas City Star, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.kansascity.com.

Copyright © 2008, The Kansas City Star, Mo.

Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

0
0
0
0
0

(0 Ratings)