JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. — Proposed legislation in Missouri is offering families money in the form of tax credits if they opt out of public school, but some homeschooling advocates are warning families not to take it.
The so-called “school choice” legislation moving through the Missouri state house is turning out to be the unpopular kid at school, with an unlikely alliance against it: homeschoolers and public school advocates both oppose it.
At a recent private event with Lake of the Ozarks homeschooling parents, activist and homeschooling mom Lisa Whitman* (who asked for anonymity, for this article) warned that — despite the word “choice” in their branding — Missouri “school choice” bills would ultimately limit homeschooling families’ choices.
That matters, since out of the approximately 1 million school-age kids in Missouri, it is estimated that 10% are homeschooled and 11% attend private schools.** Those numbers are only an estimate, as Missouri does not require registration for homeschoolers. (Whitman says homeschool families like it that way.)
Missouri’s homeschool population got a major boost when public schools shut down in 2020 and many families made a permanent move to homeschool. Only a decade ago, estimates placed Missouri’s homeschool numbers at around 2.67% of the state’s school-aged children.
“School choice” legislation — which encompasses at least a half-dozen bills in the Missouri House and Senate — has met with pushback from public schools. The Missouri National Education Association (MNEA), a public school advocacy group, has made clear its opposition to Senator Andrew Koenig’s SB 727.
At Lake of the Ozarks, the largest school district is Camdenton R-III School District. The district’s Board President Gail Griswold said she too is adamantly opposed to the panoply of “school choice” related bills in Missouri. She says the bills — which offer families tax credits to cover education expenses if they opt out of public school — would impose state regulations on homeschool families as soon as they take the money.
Some elements of “school choice” already exist in certain parts of Missouri through the MOScholars program.
Often the bills’ supporters point to Missouri’s struggling public schools. Missouri Senate Majority Leader Cindy O’Laughlin told The Missouri Independent she supported a proposal under the “school choice” umbrella that would add more state funding into the MOScholars program. “Why not?” she said. “We don’t mind spending billions on something that’s not working” (referencing public schools’ math and reading scores.)
Rather than funding programs like MOScholars, Griswold said, “We would prefer the state legislature focus on reducing the burdens on our teachers in the classroom and repeal laws that add unnecessary mandates that distract from instruction in the classroom.”
She added, “We support third party accreditation and giving schools the flexibility to respond to their local needs.”
Homeschool families spend thousands per year on educational expenses like supplies, curricula, co-op memberships, and other educational experiences, all while paying taxes to fund schools their children don’t attend. For those families, “school choice” can sound appealing at first-glance, offering thousands of dollars per child.
But Whitman warns the long-game is to use tax credits to bring families into programs that then force them to homeschool under rules crafted by state and federal bureaucracies. In Missouri, that would be the Department of the Treasury and a special board consisting of members of the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE).
She argues the money isn’t worth the tradeoff.
Similar bills last year met with minimal resistance from statewide homeschool organizations, but that appears to have changed. Robert Bortins, the CEO of Classical Conversations, a Christian homeschool organization that uses a community-based classical learning method, has come out passionately opposed to “school choice” bills. Regional and statewide groups like Missouri Freedom Initiative, Missouri Freedom Foundation, St. Charles County Parents Association, Informed Health Choice Missouri, and Burnt District Republicans oppose it too.
The board for Lake Christian Academy, located in Sunrise Beach, Mo., recently signed a grassroots statement opposing “school choice” legislation. That statement has been signed by 25 groups ranging from regional homeschool co-ops to larger organizations like Classical Conversations, which has communities across the country.
Lake Christian Academy learned the hard way about the strings attached to state and federal funds. Years ago, the school signed up for the federal milk program, to get discounted milk for students. Suddenly they found the tendrils of government creeping into Lake Christian Academy.
LCA co-founder and Board Vice President Nick Stutesman explained to Lake Expo that the school participated in the program for about five or six years. He called the reporting requirements “onerous,” and added, “As we reviewed not just the direct requirements, but verbiage that seemingly extended beyond simply providing milk at a reasonable cost… [it was] exposure we felt offset the benefits of the program.” The school reversed course, opting to buy their own milk rather than accept federal intervention.
In Missouri, Whitman warns the following bills pose a threat to homeschoolers:
SB727 (Koenig)
SB729 (Koenig)
SB1391 (Leutkemeyer)
SB1392 (Trent)
HB1615 (Hudson)
HB1671 (Mattheisen)
HB1738 (Richey)
HB2104 (Christofanelli)
Speaking to the group of Lake area homeschooling families, Whitman urged them to respectfully contact their elected officials in Jefferson City and ask them to oppose any legislation that mentions homeschooling at all. The money would be nice, she said, but the best way to keep freedom for the estimated 110,811 children who are homeschooled across Missouri is to leave them out of legislation altogether.
“With the shekels,” she said, “come the shackles.”
* Name changed to protect privacy
** Senator Andrew Koenig’s fiscal note on his SB729 estimates 110,811 children are homeschooled and 116,347 attend private schools in Missouri. With 861,494 children attending Missouri public schools, according to Missouri’s Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), that means an estimated 11% of Missouri children are homeschooled.
