Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit

Where Do We Keep The Library's Pornographic Books? Camden County Considers Limiting Kids' Access

  • Updated
  • 4 min to read

CAMDENTON, Mo. — At a packed board meeting Jan. 12, the Camden County Library District was presented with three solutions regarding age-inappropriate books in the Children's Library being available to children who have a library card.

CCLD Board President Vicky Simbro asked attendees of the Friday meeting to sign in and state their concerns, as well as their solutions to the issue. Usually the citizen comment allowance is three minutes, but the board extended the time to five minutes. 

CCLD board meeting Jan 12 - sexually graphic books discussion

At a Camden County Library District board meeting on Jan. 12, 2024, concerned citizens filled the room to capacity and shared their opinions on age-inappropriate books in the children's section.

"The board will not participate in any discussion today," Simbro informed the crowd. "We will take it all into consideration. The board and the new library director will get together, and if we have to have another meeting, we will let you know."

This issue was first brought before the CCLD board on Dec. 15, 2023 when citizens raised concerns about multiple books in the children's library with sexually inappropriate images, large amounts of profanity, and descriptions of underage drinking, sexual activities, rape, and incest. 

Child Reading In Library

According to library policy, any minor (17 & under) with a parent/guardian approved library card can have access to all of the library's materials, physical and digital.

The Missouri Secretary of State's office enacted the Library Certification Requirement for the Protection of Minors on May 30, 2023. That rule requires libraries to adopt written policies determining what materials are age appropriate. Libraries are also required to honor a parent’s decision as to what material their child has access to in the library.

Simbro said the January meeting was about reconciling materials in the library that were deemed inappropriate, which she reviewed. Two of the books brought up last month were Flamer and It Feels Good To Be Yourself.

"I have taken them off the shelf for now," Simbro said. "Until we hear from the community to get your ideas, they will not be put back until this matter comes to a conclusion."

After over an hour of public comment, three options were presented to the CCLD board:

1. Remove the age-inappropriate books from the library.

2. Remove the age-inappropriate books from the children's library and place them in a special section where children can only have access to them when accompanied by their parents.

3. Keep the books in the children's library. 

Jim Pasley, the new CCLD Director, gave the citizens a promise to address the issue with enough time.

"I don't know the staff, the process of how books are bought, where they are stored, or for how long," Pasley said. "I don't have an opinion either way. I agree with respect, and I agree libraries are for education."

The next CCLD Board of Trustees meeting is scheduled for 9 a.m. Friday, Feb. 9 at the Camdenton Library. 

Samples of commenters' opinions from the Jan. 12 meeting are below.

Book in library with old open textbook

What did Lake of the Ozarks citizens have to say? 

Those in favor of removing books:

Both Daniel Ousley and Ann Currier said this issue is about protecting children, not banning books. 

"A parent should be able to bring a child into the library and not have their child pick up a book that teaches them they can be a boy, a girl, or both, and change whenever you want to," Ousley said.

Currier was concerned that kids could walk across the street from school and pick up books without their parents' knowledge.

"One book in this library for 12 to 17-year-olds discusses having sex with teachers, children being roofied, doing drugs, and orgies, with all these things happening at school," Currier said. "This puts it in a child's mind that all these things are ok."

Victoria Howard argued that it is the parents' right to teach their children about sex, not the library. 

Teetering between two solutions was Juli Purvis, who stated the situation is primarily a moral issue and about attacks on children.

"They are going to lose their childhood if they get into this stuff too soon," Purvis said. "This gets imprinted in their brains. Any pornographic books should go, but educational ones should be put in a special section."

Those in favor of a special section in the County's libraries or reconsidering access:

Steve D. simply suggested that there should be a section that says those books require a conversation. 

Roma Long agreed, saying, "I teach my students to be respectful and not bully, regardless of race, sex, and religion. There are books in the library that are too graphic even for adults. Don't ban the books, but set up a clear section."

Camden County Presiding Commissioner Ike Skelton was also in attendance, and proposed that the board reconsider who has access to certain books in the 12 to 18-year-old section. 

"No one person in this room is into banning books," Skelton said. "But there are some books that are absolutely inappropriate for little children."

Skelton read a passage from The Hiding Place by Corrie Ten Boom to help explain his stance. He argued that adults should be the ones trusted to carry knowledge that is too heavy for children. 

"Let's look at a way to get the books into an area where the access does exist, but it is very highly regulated," Skelton said. 

Those in favor of keeping the books or concerned about removing literature:

Cindy Coffey suggested that people have issues with the books because they are about the LGBTQ community. She referenced the First Amendment and brought up parental rights and suicide among queer youth. 

Michelle Myler argued that the United States is a free country, so she was against book banning, saying, "I am a tax-paying citizen, and I want the books to remain in the library."

Karen Ketchum implored people to consider the issue through a lens of equity. "Will all children and young adults feel represented?" she asked.

Laura Scott agreed with Ketchum's point, saying she supports kids who don't feel accepted by their peers. "My oldest child is non-binary and has faced discrimination. These books are about gender identity, not sex. Leave the books in the library."

Nancy Pope said school librarians are trained to know what's best to put in libraries, adding that children are better able to protect themselves when they have information available to them. 


Related Coverage

0
0
0
0
0

(0 Ratings)