Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
Editor's Pick Hot

Kids Can Check Out Sexually Graphic Books At Camden County Library; Citizens Raise Concerns

  • Updated
  • 4 min to read
Child Reading In Library

CAMDEN COUNTY, Mo. — Disagreements about what belongs in the public library are happening nationwide, with a focus on sexually explicit books, LGBTQ-themed books, transgender issues, and drag shows presented to children. That debate has now come to the Lake.

Citizens raised serious concerns at a Camden County Library District Board of Trustees meeting on Dec. 15 in the Camdenton Library, requesting the removal of sexually graphic books from the children's section in the district. 

CCLD Board of Trustees Dec 2023 - remove age inappropriate books

Pictured from left to right are the Camden County Library District Trustees: Bill Mundhausen, John Olivarri, Adam Guttman, Interim Director Vicky Granneman, Denice Gay, and board president Vicky Simbro.

According to Camden County library policy, any minor 17 years old and under who has a parent/guardian approved library card can have access to all library materials - physical and digital. 

One concern raised at the Friday meeting was that some parents were not aware of the free access of adult books to children. 

“Kids walk across the street from the school and they have full access to all the books in the library, whether or not they have a card. They just can’t check them out,” said Camdenton Alderman Daniel Ousley to the board. “One book has a picture of a naked woman behind a man who was down on all fours. This is animated porn, and it is accessible to minors.”

Several people spoke in favor of taking out what they deemed objectionable literature from the children's library, while no one at the meeting spoke on behalf of keeping the books. 

Ousley was the first to voice his concerns. He said he personally researched the books in the district library.

“I’m not here to say certain books are to be banned. I believe in freedom and our constitution,” Ousley told the board. “Now, I do believe our tax dollars should not be used to buy books filled with pornography, or books intended to groom a child into choosing a sexual orientation before they are old enough to understand, and without their parents being involved. I also do not believe these books should be accessible to children, yet here they are. I have a box full of examples.”

In the box Ousley brought to the meeting were multiple books found in the children's library that contained explicit language and descriptions of sexual activities. Some included intercourse and descriptions of rape.

Ousley highlighted the semi-autobiographical book Flamer, a graphic novel from a 14-year-old's point of view at his Boy Scouts summer camp. He said it was found at the Camdenton branch in the 12-to-18-year-old section.

“Flamer is meant to attract young readers who like the book Diary of a Wimpy Kid,” said Ousley, who proceeded to read direct quotes from the book that he thought were concerning.

Dialogue between characters included penis jokes, the objectification of girls, homophobic and racial slurs, as well as crude and sometimes vulgar humor. There was also language around suicide ideation.

Herbert Brownell addressed the board regarding Flamer, saying, “I would be embarrassed and ashamed to read Flamer aloud in this group of adults. That alone, in itself, should prove it is not worthy to be allowed in the children’s section of this library.”

Another book brought up during the meeting was It Feels Good To Be Yourself, which Nancy Ousley read to the board. She said she felt it was not appropriate for children because it discussed being transgender. 

Ruth R., a great-great-grandmother from the area, added, "Reading that book will only confuse children." 

Cindy D. also spoke to the board: “These books are not even appropriate for adults. I wouldn’t want to pick them up and read them. This is our taxpayer dollars paying for these books and our job is to protect our children. This is porn. It is so upsetting to me that a child can pick this up in our library. Porn is in a separate room for adults at other establishments. Please take this off the shelves for children,” she requested.

Vicky Simbro, the Camden County Library District Board of Trustees President, closed the citizen portion of the meeting.

"The board hears and recognizes your concerns," Simbro said. "We will put this on the January agenda. Because of the concerns we are hearing, and what you are saying, we need time to look at our curation process and check our policies to see if we are in line with community values and state laws."

The Missouri Secretary of States office enacted Rule 15 CSR 30-200.015 Library Certification Requirement for the Protection of Minors on May 30, 2023. It requires libraries to adopt written policies determining what materials are age appropriate.

State funds cannot not be used to purchase or acquire inappropriate materials in any form for a minor as well. Libraries are required to honor a parent’s decision as to what material their child has access to in the library. Parents have the right to challenge a library’s age-appropriate designation for any material. Results of challenges must be published on a library’s website. The new policy also stops libraries from having certain events and displays in children’s areas.

Books can be challenged online or at any of the six branches in Camden County.

According to JoDonn Chaney, SOS Ashcroft’s Director of Communications, a parent can challenge a book and the library is required conduct a review. “Some already had policies in place,” Chaney said in a telephone interview. “Each library district’s policies are based on what the patrons in that district want.”

According to a National Public Radio article, librarians have criticized the set of regulations since they were first proposed, calling them an unnecessary burden when it’s already illegal to give obscene materials to minors. But Ashcroft has said the rule is simply a way for parents to be more involved in raising their children.

“It would require libraries to designate what is age appropriate and what isn't age appropriate, and to be transparent about that,” Ashcroft told KCUR in 2022, “so that parents can be in charge of how their children are raised. Foremost, we want to protect our children.” 

The next meeting of the Camden County Library District Board of Trustees is scheduled at 9 a.m., Friday, Jan. 12 at the Camdenton Library.  

"It affects the whole Camden County community," said Simbro. "We will inform the community and give everyone a chance to come and speak on this matter."

0
0
0
0
0

(0 Ratings)