It has been almost 32 years since Tammy Rothganger seemingly vanished just minutes before her first morning class at Eldon High School. After hundreds of hours of investigation, following lead after lead, a former Eldon man will now face a Capital Murder charge. Tammy’s family is surprised, but they say their greatest hope is simply to find her remains.
On Monday, Miller County Prosecutor Ben Winfrey charged Martin Dean Priest, 58, with the Class A Felony of Capital Murder.
Tammy's immediate family, who no longer reside in the Central Missouri area, said they were somewhat surprised to hear that Priest was finally charged in Tammy's death, although they have always suspected his involvement in her disappearance.
"It's been a very long time," said Sharon Leonard, Tammy's aunt. "We were surprised to hear of the charges after this long, but what we really want is Tammy."
Leonard has worked with investigators since the beginning of the case and said the family's ultimate goal is to find Tammy and give her the respectful burial she deserves.
"I want Tammy," she said. "I want to know where she is. She deserves to be laid to rest with her grandparents. She deserves that after all of this time."
Leonard said Tammy's mom and brother agree.
"We have all been through so much in the past 32 years," Leonard said. "It has been hard on our family and we just really need to find her."
At the time of Tammy's disappearance, Priest had been living with the girl and her mother in a small home across the street from the front entrance of Eldon High School, just a couple of blocks from where Tammy was reportedly seen entering a vehicle driven by Priest the morning of May 16, 1984.
Seven months after Tammy's disappearance, Priest was charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of William Mayhugh and Freida Bayliff in the Wichita, Kansas area. He was convicted in Mayhugh's death but acquitted in Bayliff's death. He has been incarcerated in the Kansas Department of Corrections since 1985. According to KDOC records, Priest will be eligible for parole on Aug. 1, 2016.
MILLER COUNTY, Mo. — The Eldon man charged with murdering a local teen in 1984 has a bloody …
According to documents dated Feb. 24, 2010 and filed in the Miller County Court on Jan. 4, 2016, investigators said a witness, referred to only by T.H., said she had been with Tammy on the morning of May 16, 1984. They had gone to the Bass Pro Shop, located at the intersection of highways 54 and 52, before school. On the way back to the school, T.H. said Priest and a juvenile male, later identified as "D.N", approached the two girls and asked Tammy to get in the car.
T.H. said that was the last time she saw Tammy.
Court documents indicate that D.N. told investigators he witnessed Priest hitting Tammy in the back of the head with a wrench, knocking her unconscious. He said Priest then raped her and strangled her until she was dead. Priest hid her body at a local residence until returning later that night, or the next, when they took her body to an unmarked location and buried her, according to D.N.’s statements depicted in court documents.
"I have no idea who T.H. or D.N. are," Leonard said. "I knew of that person's information but the family has never been told who they are."
Leonard said even with the Capital Murder charge now filed against Priest, the family's main concern is still to find Tammy.
"I want proof that she's gone," Leonard said. "We need to know where she is. It's been too many years... we just need to know."
